ben's notes

Evolutionary Thought

Your browser does not support inline PDFs. Download the PDF instead.

Evolutionary Thought #

History of Evolutionary Thought #

  • pre-darwin: transmutation of species occurred, but no hypothesis of mechanism
    • Oswald Avery, Crick + Watson: 1940s discovery of DNA

Natural Selection: #

  1. individuals vary in phenotypes
  2. phenotypic variation transmitted to offspring
  3. competition for scarce resources

Consequence: offspring w/ favorable traits have more offspring, ⇒ adaptation by natural selection

Darwin and Natural Selection #

  • 5-year voyage on Beagle as naturalist
  • Galapagos islands:
    • founder effect: evolution depends on small group of species who happened to arrive. first arrivers = little competition ⇒ more
    • adaptive radiation: diversification
      • Syms Covington unto locations, John Gould realized all collected
      • each finch had a different beak to specialize in food types

Effects of Weather: #

  • during drought, food is scarce and only food is hard seeds
  • finches begin to adapt to have larger beaks
    • those that already have big beaks more successful
  • decrease in variation in size

Evolution is not progress. #

Success is local and temporary; environments are constantly changing.

  • bush structure: current adaptations built off of historical traits, but are not always getting “better”

This also applies to cultural evolution: culture is a response to the present environment, and must build off past cultures

Sexual Selection / Kin Selection #

2 problems:

Peacock Problem: how did evolution lead to peacock tails? #

  • makes them more vulnerable to predators
  • Solution: sexual selection — competition to reproduce, need to compete within a species
    • can lead to lower survivability, higher reproductivity
  • handicap principle: expensive traits that demonstrate fitness
    • example: peacock feathers, deer antlers, widowbird tails (longer = better)
    • only the smartest, most fit individuals can survive predators w/ handicap
    • typically honest indicators (no way to cheat), eg barn swallows who have lower parasite load have longer tails
  • Sexual selection has same goal as natural selection (increase offspring), but different process
    • intrasexual: compete against same sex
    • intersexual: attract opposite sex

Honeybee Problem: why is there only one queen bee that can reproduce? #

William D Hamilton, 1964: evolution works at individual level

  • individual is vehicle for genes
  • inclusive fitness: count of genes in relatives as well as self

Hamilton’s Rule: rB > C

  • r = relatedness b/tw two individuals
  • B = benefit to recipient
  • C = cost to actor

↳ altruism makes sense when rB > C, since it increases inclusive fitness

  • example: nepotism
  • honeybees maximize inclusive fitness by helping queen reproduce, create sister workers (more closely related)